Grocott's Mail
  • NEWS
    • Courts & Crime
    • Features
    • Politics
    • People
    • Health & Well-being
  • SPORT
    • News
    • Results
    • Sports Diary
    • Club Contacts
    • Columns
    • Sport Galleries
    • Sport Videos
  • OPINION
    • Election Connection
    • Makana Voices
    • Deur ‘n Gekleurde Bril
    • Newtown… Old Eyes
    • Incisive View
    • Your Say
  • ARTSLIFE
    • Cue
    • Makana Sharp!
    • Visual Art
    • Literature
    • Food & Fun
    • Festivals
    • Community Arts
    • Going Places
  • OUR TOWN
    • What’s on
    • Spiritual
    • Emergency & Well-being
    • Safety
    • Civic
    • Municipality
    • Weather
    • Properties
      • Grahamstown Properties
    • Your Town, Our Town
  • OUTSIDE
    • Enviro News
    • Gardening
    • Farming
    • Science
    • Conservation
    • Motoring
    • Pets/Animals
  • ECONOMIX
    • Business News
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Personal Finance
  • EDUCATION
    • Education NEWS
    • Education OUR TOWN
    • Education INFO
  • Covid-19
  • EDITORIAL
  • Cue Media
    • Cue online
    • Cue Archives
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • SAC and DSG matric class of 1990 donate 64 dresses to Nathaniel Nyaluza for matric farewell
  • Children in the Eastern Cape are not being fed enough at school
  • I-Amazwi isindleke umsitho wokubhiyozela usuku lokungamafa namagugu
  • ‘Oh, the water came today’
  • Eluxolweni Child Youth Care Centre showcases young talent
  • Imvuselelo
  • Local mom wants urgent liver transplant for toddler
  • Explore Makhanda’s African Cuisine
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Grocott's Mail
  • NEWS
    • Courts & Crime
    • Features
    • Politics
    • People
    • Health & Well-being
  • SPORT
    • News
    • Results
    • Sports Diary
    • Club Contacts
    • Columns
    • Sport Galleries
    • Sport Videos
  • OPINION
    • Election Connection
    • Makana Voices
    • Deur ‘n Gekleurde Bril
    • Newtown… Old Eyes
    • Incisive View
    • Your Say
  • ARTSLIFE
    • Cue
    • Makana Sharp!
    • Visual Art
    • Literature
    • Food & Fun
    • Festivals
    • Community Arts
    • Going Places
  • OUR TOWN
    • What’s on
    • Spiritual
    • Emergency & Well-being
    • Safety
    • Civic
    • Municipality
    • Weather
    • Properties
      • Grahamstown Properties
    • Your Town, Our Town
  • OUTSIDE
    • Enviro News
    • Gardening
    • Farming
    • Science
    • Conservation
    • Motoring
    • Pets/Animals
  • ECONOMIX
    • Business News
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Personal Finance
  • EDUCATION
    • Education NEWS
    • Education OUR TOWN
    • Education INFO
  • Covid-19
  • EDITORIAL
  • Cue Media
    • Cue online
    • Cue Archives
Grocott's Mail
You are at:Home»NEWS»Scepticism and unity at meeting with the Justice Minister
NEWS

Scepticism and unity at meeting with the Justice Minister

Grocott's MailBy Grocott's MailJuly 13, 2023Updated:July 16, 2023No Comments4 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
There were more than 200 Makhanda residents at the City Hall meeting with Justice Minister Ronald Lamola
There were more than 200 Makhanda residents at the City Hall meeting with Justice Minister Ronald Lamola. Photo: Steven Lang

By Steven Lang

An incredulous gathering of Makhanda residents erupted in noisy cheers when Justice Minister Ronald Lamola said, “We are not moving the Court from Makhanda. The Court will remain here . . . “ (loud applause).

He hesitated briefly and then threw cold water on the cheers, “The only thing. . . before you clap hands, you need to understand the following. We are not moving the court. The recommendation is to move the Provincial Seat, and the Provincial Seat is not the whole court.

“It’s just the Head Office of the Court, which is the Judge President, to Bhisho” (drowned out by loud booing).

Justice Minister Ronald Lamola made a special trip to Makhanda to engage with residents about the proposed move of the High Court to Bhisho.
Justice Minister Ronald Lamola made a special trip to Makhanda to engage with residents about the proposed move of the High Court to Bhisho. Photo: Steven Lang

More than 200 sceptical residents of Makhanda met with Lamola at the Makana City Hall on Thursday morning. Makana Executive Mayor, Yandiswa Vara, had called the meeting between the Minister and concerned citizens to discuss the proposed move of the Seat of the High Court to Bhisho. In a rare showing of unity, residents from all walks of life representing every race group in the municipality shared one common objective – “Hands off our city, hands off our High Court”.

Many private citizens, civic organisations, the Makana Municipality, Rhodes University, political parties, and legal fraternities have all made submissions to the Justice Minister opposing the proposed move to the provincial capital.

While residents and several speakers acknowledged the effort the Minister had made in coming to Makhanda to engage with stakeholders, there was some cynicism about Lamola’s claim that it was the first time he had learnt the reasons for their concerns.

The Justice Minister explained that he was now considering an interim report before a final report is published either in August or September. That report will contain recommendations to guide him in taking a final decision.

He pointed out that the interim report is not exclusively about the High Court in Makhanda and cited the problem area of Hammanskraal in Gauteng Province where residents prefer having their cases heard in the North West Province.

Lamola said the rationale for the proposal is the need to rationalise the High Courts nationally because “We have not done that since 1994, and there have been changes since then in terms of the population and impacts on the courts”.

He declined to mention several previous initiatives to move the High Court. However, Rhodes University Vice Chancellor, Prof Sizwe Mabizela, noted that the Hoexter Commission, Chief Justice Arthur Chaskalson and others had done extensive research and all concluded that the High Court should remain in Makhanda, or Grahamstown as it was then called.

Rhodes University Vice Chancellor, Prof Sizwe Mabizela, said the proposed move of the High Court to Bhisho would have devastating consequences for the economy of Makhanda.
Rhodes University Vice Chancellor, Prof Sizwe Mabizela, said the proposed move of the High Court to Bhisho would have devastating consequences for the economy of Makhanda. Photo: Steven Lang

Lamola’s main argument in favour of the move centred on access to justice. He used an example of litigants who live in East London and have to go past Bhisho to get to the Makhanda High Court.

Local activist, Philip Machanick, countered this argument saying that access to justice is not simply a matter of geography. He pointed out that people wishing to use the courts in Makhanda had access to vast legal resources of the Law Faculty of Rhodes University.

Undoubtedly the most powerful argument against the move stems from the devastating economic impact of the proposed move. Various speakers quoted the excessively high unemployment figures in the area. Mabizela said an economic impact study had been made and found that “More than 5,000 jobs – direct jobs will be lost. And thousands of jobs in associated services will be lost and the economy of this town will be devastated”.

He added, “The municipality will lose revenue in terms of rates”.

Chair of the Grahamstown Business Forum, Richard Gaybba, stressed that the consequences of the move would not only affect the legal fraternity, but the whole “town would collapse”.

A leader of Makhanda’s youth repeated a warning he had made earlier to the Moseneke Commission investigating the same issue, “Moving the High Court away from Makhanda would be equivalent to a Day Zero, with no prospect of rain anytime soon”.

Former Mayor of Makana, Vumile Lwana and Rhodes University Vice Chancellor, Prof Sizwe Mabizela both spoke firmly against the proposed move of the High Court to Bhisho. Provincial Chair of Action SA, Athol Trollip is sitting behind them.
Former Mayor of Makana, Vumile Lwana and Rhodes University Vice Chancellor, Prof Sizwe Mabizela both spoke firmly against the proposed move of the High Court to Bhisho. Provincial Chair of Action SA, Athol Trollip is sitting behind them. Photo: Steven Lang
Previous ArticleRight to adequate housing not realised for Extension 7 residents
Next Article To move or not to move, that is the question
Grocott's Mail

    Comments are closed.

    Tweets by Grocotts
    Newsletter



    Listen

    The Rhodes University Community Engagement Division has launched Engagement in Action, a new podcast which aims to bring to life some of the many ways in which the University interacts with communities around it. Check it out below.

    Humans of Makhanda

    Humans of Makhanda

    Weather    |     About     |     Advertise     |     Subscribe     |     Contact     |     Support Grocott’s Mail

    © 2023 Maintained by School of Journalism & Media Studies.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.