Grocott's Mail
  • NEWS
    • Courts & Crime
    • Features
    • Politics
    • People
    • Health & Well-being
  • SPORT
    • News
    • Results
    • Sports Diary
    • Club Contacts
    • Columns
    • Sport Galleries
    • Sport Videos
  • OPINION
    • Election Connection
    • Makana Voices
    • Deur ‘n Gekleurde Bril
    • Newtown… Old Eyes
    • Incisive View
    • Your Say
  • ARTSLIFE
    • Makana Sharp!
    • Visual Art
    • Literature
    • Food & Fun
    • Festivals
    • Community Arts
    • Going Places
  • OUR TOWN
    • What’s on
    • Spiritual
    • Emergency & Well-being
    • Safety
    • Civic
    • Municipality
    • Weather
    • Properties
      • Grahamstown Properties
    • Your Town, Our Town
  • OUTSIDE
    • Enviro News
    • Gardening
    • Farming
    • Science
    • Conservation
    • Motoring
    • Pets/Animals
  • ECONOMIX
    • Business News
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Personal Finance
  • EDUCATION
    • Education NEWS
    • Education OUR TOWN
    • Education INFO
  • Covid-19
  • EDITORIAL
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • Waya-Waya: sculpting out of the wasteland 
  • When you look at me, what colour do you see?
  • Where past and present collide
  • Don’t be late! Top tips for getting to your NAF show on time 
  • Never underestimate an apology
  • The magic of Village Green
  • A new stage for the National Arts Festival
  • Showing Pride at Fest
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Grocott's Mail
Cue Media
  • NEWS
    • Courts & Crime
    • Features
    • Politics
    • People
    • Health & Well-being
  • SPORT
    • News
    • Results
    • Sports Diary
    • Club Contacts
    • Columns
    • Sport Galleries
    • Sport Videos
  • OPINION
    • Election Connection
    • Makana Voices
    • Deur ‘n Gekleurde Bril
    • Newtown… Old Eyes
    • Incisive View
    • Your Say
  • ARTSLIFE
    • Makana Sharp!
    • Visual Art
    • Literature
    • Food & Fun
    • Festivals
    • Community Arts
    • Going Places
  • OUR TOWN
    • What’s on
    • Spiritual
    • Emergency & Well-being
    • Safety
    • Civic
    • Municipality
    • Weather
    • Properties
      • Grahamstown Properties
    • Your Town, Our Town
  • OUTSIDE
    • Enviro News
    • Gardening
    • Farming
    • Science
    • Conservation
    • Motoring
    • Pets/Animals
  • ECONOMIX
    • Business News
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Personal Finance
  • EDUCATION
    • Education NEWS
    • Education OUR TOWN
    • Education INFO
  • Covid-19
  • EDITORIAL
Grocott's Mail
You are at:Home»Uncategorized»Western and alternative therapies, new bedfellows?
Uncategorized

Western and alternative therapies, new bedfellows?

_Gr0cCc0Tts_By _Gr0cCc0Tts_April 21, 2008No Comments3 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

There shouldn’t be a struggle between western medicine and complementary or alternative medicine (CAMs) says biochemist, author, and freelance science journalist Toby Murcott.  The clash between the two forms of treatment stems from the lack of scientific evidence about the success of CAMs.  

There shouldn’t be a struggle between western medicine and complementary or alternative medicine (CAMs) says biochemist, author, and freelance science journalist Toby Murcott.  The clash between the two forms of treatment stems from the lack of scientific evidence about the success of CAMs.  

The problem is that alternative therapies are difficult to test, while pharmaceutical drugs are subjected to painstaking trials to determine their safety and effectiveness, Murcott told an audience at Scifest Africa. The only evidence that alternative therapies work comes from personal success stories often from those who practice and or use traditional therapy.  For scientists who are constantly seeking objectivity and truth, this information is not credible enough, Murcott said.

However, while most drugs are testable, it is as difficult to establish the effectiveness of physiotherapy, psychiatry and surgery as it is to assess whether alternative therapies like Reiki, shiatsu and homeopathy work.  Critics of CAMs should insist on evidence for all mainstream medical treatments too, Murcott said.

He explained that research techniques from the social science – or “the science of the bleedin’ obvious” – field is increasingly being used to test alternative therapies. “These may seem commonsensical but they are fantastic at looking at how people respond to treatment,” Murcott said. 

Murcott emphasised that while the media posits traditional and alternative medicine against each other, the two can and do work together to heal people. He said that traditional medicine is effective in solving acute problems, while alternative medicine is most successful to help patients live better with chronic illnesses like arthritis.

Grahamstown medical practitioner and acupuncturist, Dr Stuart Dwyer agrees. 

“Western medicine is most useful in an emergency, trauma situation. If you are in car accident then you’ll want a surgeon to stitch you back together.” But the shortcoming of traditional medicine is that it fails to address long term chronic conditions because it treats the symptom, not the cause, Dr Dwyer said.

Placebo effect
CAMs are often seen as placebos by those who are sceptical of their effectiveness.  The placebo effect involves a patient believing in the efficacy of the treatment or medication to such an extent that the patient gets better.

“All of medicine, every bit, [with]no exception has got a bit of placebo,” Murcott said.   The placebo effect has an effect over and above the actual treatment and this applies to CAMs and western medicines alike.

Ethically, medical doctors cannot prescribe placebos. And while scientifically CAMs may be placebos, alternative health practitioners believe in their effectiveness.  This is because complementary medicine has a different way of treating patients. It attempts to treat symptoms holistically.

Local reflexologist, Jane James makes a similar point.

“Western medicine often just looks at a symptom and tries to address that symptom but often suppressing it with a drug so it’s not actually addressing the cause of the illness,” James said. CAMs, however, treat a patient by focusing on things like lifestyle instead of separate symptoms.

“There is huge increase in expenditure on complementary health or unconventional medicine. In America in the early 2000s they were spending more money on unconventional therapies than on hospital treatment,” Dwyer said. 

Previous ArticleTransit Camp leaders of mob justice brought to court
Next Article Zim protest calls for united front
_Gr0cCc0Tts_

Related Posts

Johan Carinus tree planting

Learn music fit for a king

First place for Malawian journalist- Need to upload Pix

Comments are closed.

Cue for you!
Cue for you!
Cue for you!
Tweets by Grocotts
Newsletter



Listen

The Rhodes University Community Engagement Division has launched Engagement in Action, a new podcast which aims to bring to life some of the many ways in which the University interacts with communities around it. Check it out below.

Latest video

Weather    |     About     |     Advertise     |     Subscribe     |     Contact     |     Support Grocott’s Mail

© 2022 Maintained by School of Journalism & Media Studies.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.