Grocott's Mail
  • NEWS
    • Courts & Crime
    • Features
    • Politics
    • People
    • Health & Well-being
  • SPORT
    • News
    • Results
    • Sports Diary
    • Club Contacts
    • Columns
    • Sport Galleries
    • Sport Videos
  • OPINION
    • Election Connection
    • Makana Voices
    • Deur ‘n Gekleurde Bril
    • Newtown… Old Eyes
    • Incisive View
    • Your Say
  • ARTSLIFE
    • Cue
    • Makana Sharp!
    • Visual Art
    • Literature
    • Food & Fun
    • Festivals
    • Community Arts
    • Going Places
  • OUR TOWN
    • What’s on
    • Spiritual
    • Emergency & Well-being
    • Safety
    • Civic
    • Municipality
    • Weather
    • Properties
      • Grahamstown Properties
    • Your Town, Our Town
  • OUTSIDE
    • Enviro News
    • Gardening
    • Farming
    • Science
    • Conservation
    • Motoring
    • Pets/Animals
  • ECONOMIX
    • Business News
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Personal Finance
  • EDUCATION
    • Education NEWS
    • Education OUR TOWN
    • Education INFO
  • Covid-19
  • EDITORIAL
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • Africa could lead the way in precision medicine
  • Wall-to-Wall Creation
  • Covid grant should be increased to at least R413, say civil society groups
  • National shutdown goes off peacefully in Makhanda
  • A bond forged by mentoring
  • Ibe yimpumelelo itumente yolutsha eQhorha
  • A good financial planner is indispensable
  • Exciting encounters in LFA Premier League weekend games
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Grocott's Mail
  • NEWS
    • Courts & Crime
    • Features
    • Politics
    • People
    • Health & Well-being
  • SPORT
    • News
    • Results
    • Sports Diary
    • Club Contacts
    • Columns
    • Sport Galleries
    • Sport Videos
  • OPINION
    • Election Connection
    • Makana Voices
    • Deur ‘n Gekleurde Bril
    • Newtown… Old Eyes
    • Incisive View
    • Your Say
  • ARTSLIFE
    • Cue
    • Makana Sharp!
    • Visual Art
    • Literature
    • Food & Fun
    • Festivals
    • Community Arts
    • Going Places
  • OUR TOWN
    • What’s on
    • Spiritual
    • Emergency & Well-being
    • Safety
    • Civic
    • Municipality
    • Weather
    • Properties
      • Grahamstown Properties
    • Your Town, Our Town
  • OUTSIDE
    • Enviro News
    • Gardening
    • Farming
    • Science
    • Conservation
    • Motoring
    • Pets/Animals
  • ECONOMIX
    • Business News
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Personal Finance
  • EDUCATION
    • Education NEWS
    • Education OUR TOWN
    • Education INFO
  • Covid-19
  • EDITORIAL
Grocott's Mail
You are at:Home»OUR TOWN»Municipality»How patronage kills progress
Municipality

How patronage kills progress

Sue MaclennanBy Sue MaclennanFebruary 17, 2020No Comments5 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Makana Citizens Front (MCF) councillor Philip Machanick addresses the Makana Residents Association (MRA) in this file photo. Photo: Steven Lang

By PHILIP MACHANICK

James Kleynhans Water Treatment Works (JKWTW) was meant to be upgraded to double its capacity on a project that was due to complete end 2017. Then end 2018. Then not at all. Early 2019, we have a dire water crisis as a result. Water from the west side from Waainek Water Treatment Works was soon to run out and JKWTW was producing half its rated capacity of 10 megalitres a day on a good day, sometimes nothing at all. Some areas on the east were without water for weeks, water queues at the spring outside town started to form in the early hours of the morning and Gift of the Givers was called in to save the day.

Part of the intervention by government was to ensure that the first phase of the renewed JKWTW upgrade was completed in March 2019. This restored the plant to its designed capacity and on a good day, it produces 20% more – up to 12ML/day. For much of last year Waainek continued to produce enough to avoid water outages.

A promise from the government was to fast-track the planned upgrades of JKWTW. Imagine my surprise late last year that the tender had not yet been awarded. I am still trying to track down details but understand that SMME subcontractors are an issue in litigation. Since the project is being managed by Amatola Water who are headquartered in East London, local sources are not able to shed much light.

This is not the only instance of tenders going astray. During Ted Pillay’s tenure in the first half of 2018, Beaufort Street was resurfaced and we heard that a bigger project to resurface several major roads, in dire need of attention, was to be funded. This second project is mired in litigation with no end in sight.

While Ted Pillay was acting Makana Municipal Manager, he put a stop to a project to upgrade the Alicedale Sewerage Works that was almost awarded to a contractor who failed on track record scores. Why would you award a tender to a contactor with a poor record of success?

All of this leads to one critical question: who gains from incompetent tender awards? That leads to another question. What particularly favours such a development and how can that be changed?

Government awards contracts like this on the condition that 30% be awarded to local SMMEs. That, on the face of it, looks like a good idea, in an economically-distressed region particularly. But there is a flaw in the concept. If a local economy is depressed, patronage has extra power because the only resources to be had flow from the government. Consequently, there is a temptation to steer contracts away from contractors with a strong track record towards those most likely to be compliant with rewarding patronage networks. So the 30% SMME fraction becomes the patronage slice.

This would not be such a bad thing if the job got done. As infrastructure shortfalls are remedied, the investment climate improves leading to more work. Recipients of patronage, even if not super-productive, add to local wealth.

The problem is that this model perversely incentivises failure. Why? Because if the project fails and it is essential infrastructure, it has to be done again. And the patronage networks are greased again. Worse: if infrastructure continues to fail, government funding becomes the only game in town, making patronage all the stronger.

Even the corrupt in the end lose as they become parasites killing the body they feed off.

The solution? If the government wants to promote development of SMMEs and local skills, make that a separate project. Also, heavily police essential infrastructure projects for wrongdoing – throw the full weight of the law at  any misconduct or corruption: SIU, lifestyle audits, the works. If the patronage slice is now a separate budget, it’s bad if it goes astray, but not the end of the world. If we carry on with decaying sewerage, water, roads and power infrastructure, the government becomes a ponzi scheme and there is no new income to pay for further development. Even the corrupt in the end lose as they become parasites killing the body they feed off.

So the remedy is simple. Remove the 30% SMME fraction from major infrastructure projects and instead award economically distressed municipalities grants to replace this funding. Police infrastructure projects rigorously so if any money does go astray it is out of a less essential pocket.

The cost of not doing this? An economic death spiral. Nationwide we are suffering an investment strike and our local economy is not better. More businesses are closing than opening; houses are hard to sell; jobs are scarce. Don’t tell me this isn’t a problem.

If my solution isn’t the right one, let’s hear others. One thing is for sure: we need a new approach because the old one isn’t working.

Previous ArticleMoonlight and pineapples for night runners
Next Article Kariega Beach search continues
Sue Maclennan
  • Twitter

Local journalism

Comments are closed.

Tweets by Grocotts
Newsletter



Listen

The Rhodes University Community Engagement Division has launched Engagement in Action, a new podcast which aims to bring to life some of the many ways in which the University interacts with communities around it. Check it out below.

Humans of Makhanda

Humans of Makhanda

Weather    |     About     |     Advertise     |     Subscribe     |     Contact     |     Support Grocott’s Mail

© 2023 Maintained by School of Journalism & Media Studies.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.