Grocott's Mail
  • NEWS
    • Courts & Crime
    • Features
    • Politics
    • People
    • Health & Well-being
  • SPORT
    • News
    • Results
    • Sports Diary
    • Club Contacts
    • Columns
    • Sport Galleries
    • Sport Videos
  • OPINION
    • Election Connection
    • Makana Voices
    • Deur ‘n Gekleurde Bril
    • Newtown… Old Eyes
    • Incisive View
    • Your Say
  • ARTSLIFE
    • Cue
    • Makana Sharp!
    • Visual Art
    • Literature
    • Food & Fun
    • Festivals
    • Community Arts
    • Going Places
  • OUR TOWN
    • What’s on
    • Spiritual
    • Emergency & Well-being
    • Safety
    • Civic
    • Municipality
    • Weather
    • Properties
      • Grahamstown Properties
    • Your Town, Our Town
  • OUTSIDE
    • Enviro News
    • Gardening
    • Farming
    • Science
    • Conservation
    • Motoring
    • Pets/Animals
  • ECONOMIX
    • Business News
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Personal Finance
  • EDUCATION
    • Education NEWS
    • Education OUR TOWN
    • Education INFO
  • Covid-19
  • EDITORIAL
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • As whistleblowers come forward, it’s our duty to protect them
  • Makhanda Fire Brigade praised by residents
  • Two deaths shock Makhanda
  • After a turbulent period, South Africa’s oldest campus radio station, RMR 89.7 FM, celebrates radio licence renewal
  • Makana Residents Association and Makhanda Business Forum to join forces
  • “It’s not like there are NO services” – Makana mayor
  • Makhanda mourns Eusebius McKaiser
  • Kivitts shines in a bonus point win for Brumbies
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Grocott's Mail
  • NEWS
    • Courts & Crime
    • Features
    • Politics
    • People
    • Health & Well-being
  • SPORT
    • News
    • Results
    • Sports Diary
    • Club Contacts
    • Columns
    • Sport Galleries
    • Sport Videos
  • OPINION
    • Election Connection
    • Makana Voices
    • Deur ‘n Gekleurde Bril
    • Newtown… Old Eyes
    • Incisive View
    • Your Say
  • ARTSLIFE
    • Cue
    • Makana Sharp!
    • Visual Art
    • Literature
    • Food & Fun
    • Festivals
    • Community Arts
    • Going Places
  • OUR TOWN
    • What’s on
    • Spiritual
    • Emergency & Well-being
    • Safety
    • Civic
    • Municipality
    • Weather
    • Properties
      • Grahamstown Properties
    • Your Town, Our Town
  • OUTSIDE
    • Enviro News
    • Gardening
    • Farming
    • Science
    • Conservation
    • Motoring
    • Pets/Animals
  • ECONOMIX
    • Business News
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Personal Finance
  • EDUCATION
    • Education NEWS
    • Education OUR TOWN
    • Education INFO
  • Covid-19
  • EDITORIAL
Grocott's Mail
You are at:Home»ARTS & LIFE»History»Clairvoyance, Clarity and Chaos: the Murder of Edith Pinnock
History

Clairvoyance, Clarity and Chaos: the Murder of Edith Pinnock

Grocott's Mail ContributorsBy Grocott's Mail ContributorsOctober 9, 2017Updated:October 26, 2017No Comments5 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
110 years ago in Grocott’s Mail… in the archives with Kylie van Zyl

In October and November 1907, Grahamstown was the scene of a sad and bizarre murder trial that occupied hundreds of column inches in both Grocott’s Mail and its rival, the now-defunct Graham’s Town Journal. The murder was never really solved, for all that one man was brought to trial three times, and the mystery continues to this day.

On Tuesday 8 October, an 11-year-old girl named Edith Pinnock was sent by her mother to buy potted meat and a loaf of bread. They lived at the Cradock Toll House, roughly where the turnoff to Rautenbach Road is now, across from the old Grahamstown golf links. The shop, belonging to a Mr Jabez South, was at the corner of Somerset and New Streets. Edith left home at about 11am. It was about five kilometres from her home to the shop and back, and perhaps Edith, who had already done the route once earlier that day, just didn’t feel like rushing. On her way home she greeted a friend on the corner of Somerset and Worcester Streets, and was a little bit later she was seen by two St Andrews Prep boys at the bridge over the railway line on Cradock Road. That was the last anyone saw of her alive.

Edith’s body was found several days later under the old Golf Club clubhouse (not the present building, but the one which burned down in 1915). The Golf Club’s caretaker, a young man named Thomas Kerr, was arrested for her murder and sent to trial in later October. He pleaded innocent, but at first glance the evidence against him looked strong: he had been seen approaching the bridge by the Prep boys while Edith was there, he was her family’s nearest neighbour, his living quarters in the clubhouse smelled like disinfectant, and he had a bad reputation as a drinker and general lowlife. His defence was that he had simply not been there – the Prep boys, who didn’t know him, couldn’t be sure it was him, and he had been at his mother’s house on South Street for some of the day, and had seen his brother-in-law there. He had been in town, selling some tools and drinking at a bar, for the rest of the day; he had returned to the Clubhouse, with a friend, much later and fallen into a drunken sleep. He acknowledged that he knew Edith Pinnock – he had even been helping searchers to dredge the Cradock Dam for her body when the police came to arrest him – but denied strongly, and repeatedly, that he had done anything to her. He explained the disinfectant smell as the result of a self-administered treatment for syphilis.

The sack that Edith’s body had been found in could have been used by Kerr, but also by anyone else who came to the Golf Club in the months it had been lying there. The bread she had had with her was never found, and the tins of potted meat that were found near her body couldn’t be linked to anybody but Jabez South, who wasn’t a suspect, and Edith herself.

The prosecution’s case wasn’t helped by the way that Edith’s body had been discovered. South, owner of the shop Edith had visited before disappearing, claimed that he had identified the killer with the help of a friend of his and young man named Staples, who lived in what is now Sunnyside. Staples and South both claimed to be clairvoyant, and South insisted that he had somehow been guided to the name “Thomas Kerr” by forces unknown. He, Staples and the third man had gone to the Golf Club and looked under the house – and there found Edith.

The judge dismissed this as utter nonsense. Unfortunately for South, he performed badly on the witness stand, insisting that he had not seen Edith turn right up Somerset Street when she left his shop despite previously saying that he had watched her through the shop window. He became muddled and aggressive, and his testimony lost credibility. The Grahamstown detectives didn’t cover themselves in glory either.They had, it seemed, failed to properly investigate or even to properly search for Edith while she was missing. Ultimately, with Kerr able to prove his whereabouts and the prosecution’s case as weak as a wet cornflake, the judge acquitted and released him.

Kerr was re-arrested on a technicality shortly thereafter, as he was trying to leave for King William’s Town (on foot), but a second trial in Grahamstown also failed to secure a conviction. Upon his second arrest, the case was tried in Cape Town – but he was once again acquitted. Kerr always maintained his innocence, and although there are rumours of a deathbed confession of guilt, nobody has ever managed to conclusively prove otherwise.

Nobody knows for sure who killed Edith Pinnock. Kerr might have done it, but he swore he was innocent, and the courts believed him. The police failed to investigate any other possibilities. Indeed, they pretty much failed to investigate Kerr, let alone any other likely suspects. Forensic science at the time was very basic when it came to trace evidence, and there wasn’t much to go on anyway. The courts back then didn’t believe in clairvoyants anymore than they do now. It is just possible – and this writer’s fondest hope – that a document may yet come to light revealing the real fate of Edith Pinnock. But it seems all too likely that the case will remain a mystery.

Queries, suggestions, tips and corrections to nervousflamingo@gmail.com.

Previous Article110 YEARS AGO IN GROCOTT’S MAIL: 13 OCTOBER 2017
Next Article 20 OCTOBER IN HISTORY
Grocott's Mail Contributors

Grocott's Mail Contributors includes content submitted by members of the public, and public and private institutions and organisations - regular and occasional, expert and citizen, opinion and analysis.

Comments are closed.

Tweets by Grocotts
Newsletter



Listen

The Rhodes University Community Engagement Division has launched Engagement in Action, a new podcast which aims to bring to life some of the many ways in which the University interacts with communities around it. Check it out below.

Humans of Makhanda

Humans of Makhanda

Weather    |     About     |     Advertise     |     Subscribe     |     Contact     |     Support Grocott’s Mail

© 2023 Maintained by School of Journalism & Media Studies.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.