Grocott's Mail
  • NEWS
    • Courts & Crime
    • Features
    • Politics
    • People
    • Health & Well-being
  • SPORT
    • News
    • Results
    • Sports Diary
    • Club Contacts
    • Columns
    • Sport Galleries
    • Sport Videos
  • OPINION
    • Election Connection
    • Makana Voices
    • Deur ‘n Gekleurde Bril
    • Newtown… Old Eyes
    • Incisive View
    • Your Say
  • ARTSLIFE
    • Cue
    • Makana Sharp!
    • Visual Art
    • Literature
    • Food & Fun
    • Festivals
    • Community Arts
    • Going Places
  • OUR TOWN
    • What’s on
    • Spiritual
    • Emergency & Well-being
    • Safety
    • Civic
    • Municipality
    • Weather
    • Properties
      • Grahamstown Properties
    • Your Town, Our Town
  • OUTSIDE
    • Enviro News
    • Gardening
    • Farming
    • Science
    • Conservation
    • Motoring
    • Pets/Animals
  • ECONOMIX
    • Business News
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Personal Finance
  • EDUCATION
    • Education NEWS
    • Education OUR TOWN
    • Education INFO
  • Covid-19
  • EDITORIAL
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • In the words of Nelson Mandela, “To deny people their human rights is to challenge their very humanity”
  • Avbob 2023 Poetry Competition Winner: Sithembele Isaac Xhegwana of Makhanda
  • Flooding at the James Kleynhans Water Treatment Works
  • Avbob 2023 Poetry Competition Second Place: Jeannie Wallace McKeown of Makhanda
  • Residents of Extensions Nine, 10, Transit Camp, Phumlani and Enkanini voice discontent!
  • Makhanda Creatives Speak Out
  • Running towards a drug and alcohol-free Makhanda
  • What’s On 23 – 30 March
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Grocott's Mail
  • NEWS
    • Courts & Crime
    • Features
    • Politics
    • People
    • Health & Well-being
  • SPORT
    • News
    • Results
    • Sports Diary
    • Club Contacts
    • Columns
    • Sport Galleries
    • Sport Videos
  • OPINION
    • Election Connection
    • Makana Voices
    • Deur ‘n Gekleurde Bril
    • Newtown… Old Eyes
    • Incisive View
    • Your Say
  • ARTSLIFE
    • Cue
    • Makana Sharp!
    • Visual Art
    • Literature
    • Food & Fun
    • Festivals
    • Community Arts
    • Going Places
  • OUR TOWN
    • What’s on
    • Spiritual
    • Emergency & Well-being
    • Safety
    • Civic
    • Municipality
    • Weather
    • Properties
      • Grahamstown Properties
    • Your Town, Our Town
  • OUTSIDE
    • Enviro News
    • Gardening
    • Farming
    • Science
    • Conservation
    • Motoring
    • Pets/Animals
  • ECONOMIX
    • Business News
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Personal Finance
  • EDUCATION
    • Education NEWS
    • Education OUR TOWN
    • Education INFO
  • Covid-19
  • EDITORIAL
Grocott's Mail
You are at:Home»Uncategorized»Advocate resigns from ‘tarnished’ JSC
Uncategorized

Advocate resigns from ‘tarnished’ JSC

Grocott's MailBy Grocott's MailApril 22, 2013No Comments4 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

Grahamstown-based advocate Izak Smuts has resigned from the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) after heated debate on the topic of transformation and the appointment of two positions on the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in Cape Town last week.

Grahamstown-based advocate Izak Smuts has resigned from the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) after heated debate on the topic of transformation and the appointment of two positions on the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in Cape Town last week.

Smuts was asked by the JSC to lead an internal discussion on transformation within the commission.

Documentation was leaked to the media earlier this month, leading to rigorous discussion that spilled over into an interview for a position in the appellate court.

Judge Clive Plasket, also from the Eastern Cape, was questioned about his position on transformation for just under two hours, even though he was being interviewed for a position on the SCA.

Smuts feels Plasket was targeted because of his reputation for independent thinking and previous cases he had presided over in which he ruled against the government.

“He was treated very unfairly,” Smuts said. “I don't think it's a secret that there is unhappiness in government about the fact that the Bench corrects them when they behave unconstitutionally.”

He pointed out that the two other High Court judges under review for the positions – they have subsequently been recommended for appointment – were not subjected to the same rigorous questioning.

Halima Saldulker was asked about it superficially, and the topic was not even broached in Nigel Willis's 40-minute interview – although he did joke about his previous differences with the Constitutional Court.

“If it was such an important element of what makes a judge suitable or unsuitable for appointment, they can't justify discussing it to such an extent with only one of the candidates,” Smuts argued.

“They behaved arbitrarily, and therefore irrationally.”

In a scathing media statement announcing his resignation from the JSC, Smuts refers to the commission's tarnished reputation and “disturbing” history: it has been involved repeatedly in unsuccessful litigation about the way in which it conducts its affairs.

He highlighted a common perception about the Commission's bias against appointing suitable white male candidates to the bench.

He called their position unconstitutional and urged them to “come clean” about their appointment practices.

“The Commission is informed by the Constitution,” he explained.

Explicit provisions regarding the role and responsibilities of the commission are laid out there.

“The word 'transformation' is not used anywhere,” Smuts said. “In the discussion document, I suggested caution in attributing such a politically-loaded role to the Commission when their role is already clearly defined by the Constitution – it is then opened up to subjective interpretation.”

“The duty of our courts is not only to resolve differences, but also to make judgments that indicate what is right and wrong for the rest of us,” he said, explaining the call for “intellectual leadership” in his statement.

“It's not just about sex and race: it is much more nuanced than that,” he said. “It's not just white males who are being chased away, but many intellectual, independent-thinking candidates whose talents are being wasted.”

He said the JSC has missed the opportunity to shape the debate around transformation in its unwillingness to discuss it openly, and it was now in the hands of the public.

Unlike promotions in the business world, judicial appointments affect justice and fairness for many people. Smuts feels that the JSC should be making appointments based on merit only.

“There are litigants of all races and both sexes that come to court for justice and equality – they deserve the best possible judgments,” Smuts said.

Previous ArticleVIDEO: Silent protest heard across SA
Next Article All G’town roads lead to ruin
Grocott's Mail

Comments are closed.

Tweets by Grocotts
Newsletter



Listen

The Rhodes University Community Engagement Division has launched Engagement in Action, a new podcast which aims to bring to life some of the many ways in which the University interacts with communities around it. Check it out below.

Humans of Makhanda

Humans of Makhanda

Weather    |     About     |     Advertise     |     Subscribe     |     Contact     |     Support Grocott’s Mail

© 2023 Maintained by School of Journalism & Media Studies.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.